The Billings Outpost

typewriter imageLetters to the Editor...
 

Legislative coup d’etat

A lawsuit is pending against the state of Montana to nullify the passage of Senate Bill 262 Confederated Salish Kootenai Tribes Water Compact, as it did not garner the two-thirds majority vote required to give the state immunity from lawsuits, thereby making it unconstitutional under Montana law.

In spite of this, Gov. [Steve] Bullock has hastily signed the defective bill into law. When a governor and his attorney general switch their allegiance from their state to a new allegiance with the feds and Indian tribes, the entire state remains at risk and open to assault and takeover by aggressive federal agencies and tribal governments. The ingredients of power and money have trumped the rule of law and resulted in corruption at the highest levels of our state government. 

However, the CSKT Water Compact would not have passed without the help of strategically placed Republicans assisting the Democrats in staging a coup of the Montana Legislature in order to pass both the Water Compact and Medicaid expansion bill, top priority items this session for federal control of Montana’s sovereignty.

They did this using a similar game plan arranged beforehand. These pivotal Rs schemed with the Ds to bend and change the rules in order to pass egregious bills that would not have passed otherwise.

Here are the Rs who voted with the Ds and were traitors to their party platforms and the constituents who voted for them:

Senate: Duane Ankney (Colstrip), Taylor Brown (Huntley), Edward Buttrey (Great Falls), Pat Connell (Hamilton),  Brian Hoven (Great Falls),  Llew Jones (Conrad), Bruce Tutvedt (Kalispell), Chas Vincent (Libby).

House: Tom Richmond (Lockwood), Tom Berry (Roundup), Christy Clark (Choteau),  Rob Cook (Conrad), Geraldine Custer (Forsyth), Steve Fitzpatrick (Great Falls), Roy Hollandsworth (Brady), Daniel Salomon (Ronan), Ray Shaw (Sheridan), Jeffrey Welborn (Dillon), G. Bruce Meyers (Box Elder).

Thank you to the Lewistown Tea Party (www.lewistownteaparty.com/) and NorthWest Liberty News (http://northwestlibertynews.com/) for sharing the complete voting records of the Republicans who sided with the Democrats.

Mae Woo

Billings

Last Updated on Thursday, 21 May 2015 12:19

Hits: 355

Schools embrace recycling

As the recycling educator for Recycle Montana, I have spent the past five months speaking with students all across the state. During that time I’ve had the pleasure of reaching more than 1,500 students through 35 presentations at 14 schools.

I’d like to thank the students, teachers and administrators in Billings, Laurel, Lockwood, Columbus, Missoula, Deer Lodge, Helena, Kalispell, Ronan and Pablo for inviting Recycle Montana to help reduce waste in their schools and making these events successful.

I’d also like to thank the Montana Department of Environmental Quality for their support and a successful partnership with the Montana SMART Schools Challenge. We hope to see even more schools registered for the challenge next year.

We were very excited to spend May 11-15 speaking with students in Big Fork, Columbia Falls and Whitefish. Presentations for schools in any area can still be scheduled for the remaining weeks of the academic year – interested schools should contact me at (406) 461-9106 or This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. .

This summer we will continue to travel, targeting festivals and similar events to assist with the development of long-term recycling programs. We are also gearing up to produce a statewide recycling guide for communities across the state. You can be a part of this project by contacting Recycle Montana with information about materials collected for recycling in your town. We would like to put your town on the map – literally – at RecycleMontana.org. By working together we will reach our goal of making recycling accessible for all Montanans.

Rob Pudner

Recycle Montana

Last Updated on Thursday, 21 May 2015 12:18

Hits: 308

Why did SB 416 fail?

It’s a shame that a minority within the Montana House of Representatives killed Senate Bill 416, the infrastructure bill. I think it’s important for folks to know how and why this happened.

At the start of the 2015 legislative session, Gov. Steve Bullock proposed an ambitious $400 million infrastructure program that used both cash and bonds to build and maintain projects across the entire state. This was killed because some representatives were reluctant to borrow low-interest money while eastern Montana felt that their needs were not being prioritized.

Nobody doubts that Eastern Montana has a need to build and improve its infrastructure. Roads are crumbling due to heavy traffic truck traffic while water and sewer works must be updated in order to handle the population increase that has come as a result of the oil boom. That being the case, there are some valid concerns about sending more money to these communities.

To put things in perspective, there are more people living in Gallatin County than all of the counties east of Billings combined. Although our county is the fastest growing in the state (with a 33 percent increase over the last 15 years) we have expanded our infrastructure through a combination of bonding, impact fees, levies and property taxes. We didn’t go to the state coffers for these expenses.

Why can’t Eastern Montana do the same thing? Well, it’s more challenging because those counties still have low population density, yet there is valid concern that these communities should shoulder a larger portion of infrastructure costs than they were initially proposing. What is much more frustrating is that many legislators like me feel that energy companies are not paying a fair share for what they take and what they break.

The prime example of this is that petroleum companies currently do not pay taxes on their first 18 months of production. This is a sweetheart deal that is costing our state millions of dollars. All attempts at amending or repealing these tax breaks were fiercely resisted by Eastern Montana representatives.

The speaker of the House, a representative from eastern Montana, proposed HB 402, which would have used much of the state’s cash reserves for infrastructure needs in Eastern Montana. Many legislators felt that sending all the available cash to the east would be unfair. Additionally, there is a possibility that our boom will soon turn to bust. The question arose: Should we put state funds into projects communities may not need in the near future and that local governments won’t be able to maintain?

In response to what was becoming an impasse, during the last month of the session a group of representatives and senators from both sides of the aisle crafted a compromise bill: SB 416. This $150 million bill combined both cash and low-interest bonding to fund projects needed all over the state including many projects in Eastern Montana. In addition to capital building projects, SB 416 created a water project grant program that prioritized communities that have shown a desire to tax themselves for some of their expenses. That’s compromise on many levels, so why did this bill fail?

After  SB 416 sailed through the Senate on a 47-3 vote, the wheels came off when the bill arrived at the House of Representatives. The rhetoric focused mostly on politics, not policy and was summarized by Rep. Art Wittich, R-Belgrade, who reminded the Republican caucus that the Tea Party faction had “lost” on three main issues leading up to that point: Medicaid expansion, The Confederated Salish Kootenai Tribes water compact and campaign finance reform. By killing the infrastructure bill, the ultra conservative faction would go home with a “win.”

Apparently, “winning” was enough reason to cause some folks to pull their support from the bill and SB 416 failed by one vote.

The question is now, Who has won and who has lost?

Rep. Tom Woods

Bozeman

Last Updated on Thursday, 14 May 2015 15:05

Hits: 589

Church should keep promise

In 1997 when the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints temple in west Billings was proposed, various representations were made to the citizens of Billings. Among the promises to the community was an assurance that the land around the temple would be developed for single-family residential use to serve as a buffer for the neighborhood residents. The land in Rim Point Subdivision was zoned and platted to reflect this promise.

After building only one home in the subdivision, the church is now back requesting a zoning exemption to the residential zoning. The church is asking to build a second megachurch in the neighborhood, a meetinghouse of approximately 20,000 square feet together with a two-acre asphalt parking lot.

If this project is approved, the Rim Point Subdivision neighborhood will no longer be primarily residential but will become a campus of megachurches. The church needs to be held to their promise and the zoning exemption denied. 

Harvey Bonner

Billings

Last Updated on Thursday, 14 May 2015 15:04

Hits: 443

Cleanup a success

Dear friends and volunteers who came forward to make the Great American Cleanup 2015 something we can all be proud of:

What a Great Cleanup! We had some rain, yes, but it didn’t stop those groups that were determined or those that postponed a day or so. The following Saturday, May 2, had a little more sunshine. All in all, what actually began before April 25 was a very rewarding experience. Seems as though many more of our citizens are taking notice of the litter and want to do something about it, and actually are doing it. And a big thank you goes to our national sponsors that continue to answer our call for supplies.

It is all behind us for now but we all know that a little clean up during the summer and come fall before the snow flies we need to take notice again of how and where we can get Yellowstone County ready for the Holidays.  Thank you seems so little to say to everyone. But please know that Bright n’ Beautiful says it from the heart. Bless you all.

Helen Johnson

Bright n’ Beautiful

Last Updated on Thursday, 14 May 2015 15:03

Hits: 564

Ir-Responsible Republicans

The following Republicans voted with Democrats consistently this legislative session: Reps. Rob Cook of Conrad, Christy Clark of Choteau, Roy Hollandsworth of Brady, Frank Garner of Kalispell, Geraldine Custer of Forsyth, Tom Berry of Roundup, Tom Richmond of Billings, Steve Fitzpatrick of Great Falls, Ray Shaw of Sheridan, Jeff Welborn of Dillon and Dan Salomon of Ronan.

Montana Citizens voted for a Republican Majority in both the State House and State Senate.

The Montana Republican Party has a platform that was drafted and voted on by all 56 Republican County Central Committees.

These 11 Ir-Responsible Republicans ran as Republicans, lied to voters that they will vote for what is best but have continually voted with the Democrats.

These 11 Ir-Responsible Republicans have blown up our State House Chamber, turning their backs on their voters and the Republican Party plus have suspended all the RULES by voting with the Democrats – now Montana will get Obamacare, the tribes will control Montana water, and now Gov. Bullock will get everything he wanted – It is a sad day in the history of Montana – these 11 should be ashamed of themselves.

When our taxes rise once again to support their ridiculous votes, don’t say you weren’t warned.

Ken Matthiesen

Plains

Last Updated on Thursday, 30 April 2015 11:07

Hits: 135

Copyright 2012 Wild Raspberry Inc.

Top Desktop version